Links not redirecting to individual posts

I used the plugin Friday to redirect my blogspot links to my new wp site. I thought I followed all the directions. Apparently not? I switched blogspot back to classic template. The Verify Configuration shows matching links, yet if I click on say--a pinterest pin linked to a blogspot post--it redirects to my new wp home page, not the actual post.

My blogspot : New WP:

What steps am I missing?

I think you are using the hostgator hosting for your WordPress site. If yes, please follow this article Hopefully hostgator team help you to solve issues.

Thanks, --Nitun