FFMPEG Plugin or Kaltura


#1

Hey there…

Just wondering if you could provide some insight into what the key differences between working with Kaltura and your Kaltura plugin, or with your FFMPEG plugin.

Besides the fact that Kaltura doesn’t do audio conversion, what are the main differences? What would compel you to choose one over the other? Is one more reliable/better supported? Do they both work for mobile?

Thanks!


#2

@jaemaz

You guessed audio-feature difference right. :slight_smile:

We are in process of creating a page to provide a comparison table for all 3 video-solutions we provide (there is third, video-encoding as service feature we provide here - http://rtcamp.com/rtmedia/addons/audio-video-encoding-service/ )

Sticking to FFMPEG v/s Kaltura Addons:
We do not have any feature is pipeline to be added to Kaltura Addon. It is mostly for users who uses kaltura already or like kaltura for their player/analytics/reports etc feature.

In case of FFMPEG, all we are doing is raw audio/video encoding. For job-queue, we are using node.js - http://github.com/rtCamp/media-node

FFMPEG-addon for sure is more CPU/resource friendly. It doesn’t have any analytic/reporting feature (we assume wordpress sites already use Google Analytics, JetPack stats or some other analytics so no need to add analytics again in video backend).

We will be adding more features to media-node as we use it for our audio/video encoding service. Some of these feature will be available for FFMPEG users.

A key difference is FFMPEG-addon requires VPS/Dedicated server so you can install media-node. For Kaltura-addon you can use kaltura.com or kaltura-on-prem account to skip installing Kaltura-CE.

But again if VPS/dedicated is a reason for going with Kaltura.com, then http://rtcamp.com/rtmedia/addons/audio-video-encoding-service/ is a nice alternative.

Rest assured both addons are developed by us and bug fixes (if any) will be covered for free by our promise - http://rtcamp.com/promise

Though we cannot guarantee future of Kaltura-CE server. They have history of NOT giving upgrade scripts when they go for major releases. That is only reason that we choose to create our own media-node!

If you have any more questions or need any details, feel free to ask.

Thanks.


#3

@jaemaz

We have created comparsion page for different encoding soltutions - http://rtcamp.com/rtmedia/addons/compare-encoding-solutions/

Please have a look at above link.

If you have any questions after that, feel free to ask.


#4

Hi Raul,

I looked at the comparison chart and still have one question. For your in-house encoding service, are the files secure? My client is concerned about that piece.

Cheers,
JM


#5

@jaemaz

Our in-house encoding service uses same server on which we host our main sites. So they are constantly monitored for intrusion.

Still, data transferred between your server and our server is not encrypted in any way. We keep deleting videos generally after 7 days if encoding is successful. Failed files are manually flushed once in a while.

If data is sensitive, I will recommend using FFMPEG-addon on your server. If your server is not VPS or dedicated, you can still make use of any VPS/dedicated machine for private encoding usage.


#6