Can't revert from wildcard ssl to normal ssl

I created wpmu with subdomains with wildcard SSL.
Then I deleted the site with the “ee site delete” command.
Then I created a new wpmu with subdirectories with normal SSL and the SSL verification failed because it keeps using the wildcard validation behind the scenes.

I know there’s some leftover data somewhere because it works perfectly when I created the wpmu with subdirectories with wildcard SSL. I just can’t go back to normal SSL for some reason.

When I created a new site (new domain) with normal SSL, it works perfectly. It only fails when I delete the wildcard-ssl site and create it again with normal SSL.